
The revised edition of “Make Fresh Milk Paint” is at the printer, and expected to ship at the end of November. It’s almost twice as long as the first edition, and features a new cover color so it’s easily distinguished from the first edition: a cheerful earthy orange (a fine color to mix from quark, lime and fancy dirt). So what contributed to those additional pages? Read on, as author Nick Kroll takes you through the changes.

Nick here! Thank you all for taking a leap of faith and making your own fresh milk paint. And thanks again to everyone who reached out to give feedback, asked for help and experimented with their own techniques. I never imagined how many of you would join me in destroying our kitchens, but I am sincerely grateful to every one of you.
Over the past year, I’ve (again) made an obscene amount of paint. Good (and bad) ideas were tested to refine the process. We ran experiments to find reliable solutions for common issues. Many of you raced up that learning curve and broke new ground.
The result of this effort is that the revised edition is now twice as long at just under 200 pages, with about 75-percent more text and many new images. Thanks everyone who contributed pictures of their projects!
There are additions spread throughout the book, but the most important updates are as follows. You’ll find more details and a few surprises if you wish to purchase the book, but the relevant topics are:
A deep dive on lime
This new chapter on lime covers types, including dolomitic vs calcitic lime, where to source, handling tips, etc. You can use almost any hydrated lime (calcium hydroxide) that you can find, except the “Hi-Yield” brand seems to have issues when used for paint.
Pigment guide
• There’s more detail on using pigments, but the core sentiment remains: Get a lot of pigments, blend them like you don’t know the rules, and enjoy. It would be a dull world if we all followed the same recipe for green.
• A rundown of every pigment formula will just give you anxiety as you try to figure out their exact composition. Practically any pigment will somehow work, given enough patient coats. The exceptions are non-lime compatible pigments such as Milori blue/Prussian blue. But the chemistry of the pigment does affect handling.
• Iron oxide red/yellow/black pigments are foolproof and cover very well with two to three coats. Start with one of those to build confidence.
• Copper phaltho blues are translucent for multiple coats and the lighter versions can take eight or more coats – definitely not the place to start for your first batch. But you can make these work once you get a little experience. And they look great when done right.
• If you want light colors (i.e. sky blue), dark pigments tinted with a little titanium white gives great coverage with minimal effort.
• Many coats in a short time frame can cause flaking paint. Go slow, especially with any pigment that needs more than three or four coats. Later coats will need more drying time. Repair any flaking by sanding those spots to bare wood and repainting those spots – they’ll blend in fine.
• Pigment names change between brands and over time, so there is no “buy this exact pigment to get this color” shopping list. A little mystery is important to the creative process. Better to get pigments you can easily find locally and experiment with them, rather than hunting down Kossoghol Blue. I still don’t like mica pigments, but I won’t stop you from making Quarkschläger.
• Also not included: “Where should I order pigments from” because this can change over the years. Currently, earthpigments.com (U.S.) and ocres-de-france.com (Europe) are excellent sources. But any local art supply shop is also a good source.
• Magic ratio by weight = 10 parts plain paint base : 1 part pigment. Infinite scaling up or down.

Techniques
• Plenty more details in the technique section, but the most important rules remain: Apply thick paint, thinly. Watery paint is bad. Draw out the paint, don’t slop it on. Let it dry well between coats.
• Adhesion issues most frequently came from too many coats in a short time; the new coat causes earlier coats to fail. Allow more drying/curing time between coats, especially with blues and phathlo greens.
• Use less pigment for translucent color wash instead of watery paint.
• Use more pigment (up to 40 grams) if the pigment is weak.
• Burnishing can add instant depth and character.
• You can paint walls. Yes, also over existing latex. But too much paint (water) per coat will cause the old latex to peel off the drywall.
• Exterior use is possible, but the paint will wear with the elements. Topcoats and sloped/vertical surfaces are key. Avoid standing water.
• For the love of all things holy, do not boil watery paint to try to thicken it.
• Don’t try to annihilate the paint in the blender. Short bursts are fine. Blending more than about 30 second in total can lead to paint curing into a thick mess.
• My apologies to everyone for not warning that thick paint can gel up solid overnight in the fridge. You can blend with water to recover or start over. It is preventable; a little extra water mixed in before storage prevents this. But there is a fine tipping point; you don’t want extra watery paint in the morning. Cal Mexicana (a lime) is also prone to delayed gelling. The same goes for low humidity environments, etc. Aiming to finish painting in one day (or half batches) avoids these challenges.
Troubleshooting
Much of the troubleshooting section came from interactions with you all. So it’s only fair that that section is available here for free download, no sign-up needed—just click to download:
I’m looking forward to seeing your brushes in action. Feel free to reach out with any questions to me on Instagram or Substack. I’m also happy to see pics of your work!























