This week I will install a leg vise on my Holtzapffel workbench in our sunroom, which is my shop on the first floor. I’ve had a twin-screw vise on Holtzapffel since I built it six years ago; when I’m done with this leg vise, I’ll be able to switch between leg vise and twin-screw with ease.
I’ve wanted to add a leg vise to the Holtzapffel for a long time, but I waited for one single reason: I wanted to use a Benchcrafted Classic metal screw on the bench. Jameel and Father John Abraham have been developing this vise for a long time, and I finally received my hardware while I was away in either Alaska or Maryland.
I’m going to install the Classic screw in tandem with Benchcrafted’s Crisscross Retro, a piece of hardware I’ve been sitting on impatiently for many months now.
My hope is this will be the most highly evolved form of metallic leg vise yet.
This morning I pulled out all the bits and pieces of the vise so I could plan out the maple vise chop. Handling Benchcrafted hardware is like holding jewelry, and the Classic is equal parts “space age” and “bad-ass.” The screw has a double-lead acme thread, which moves smoothly and quickly (1/2” per rotation). That’s very fast (check out the video on the Benchcrafted site). The machining on the screw and nut are fantastically smooth.
On the other hand, the hub, Tommy bar and flange are “Parkerized” like a firearm, which protects the surface from rust and is way cooler than paint.
The Tommy bar is also thoughtfully designed. The metal ends unscrew. And the way the Tommy bar interacts with the hub is quite cool. There is a detent in the Tommy bar that intersects with a spring-loaded plunger in the hub. This allows you to lock the Tommy bar in the middle of its length for coarse adjustments. Or you can let it swing free for maximum leverage.
It’s almost like magic.
I haven’t been this excited about vise hardware in a long time. If you are considering adding a leg vise or are building a new bench this year, I recommend you take a hard look at the Benchcrafted Classic and Crisscross combination.
— Christopher Schwarz
P.S. I know commenters are going to ask me to compare this to a wooden screw. Save your breath. It’s an aesthetic choice more than a functional one in my opinion. Wooden screws like those from Lake Erie are on par with the quality of the Benchcrafted stuff. So it’s like handplane bodies. Which do you prefer: metallic or wooden? They both work great.
Nice review. I was on the fence though the hardware looked amazing.
I am not a bench geek. It is a tool to me but this vise actually got me excited after I watched there video months ago.
I think I just might take the plunge. 👍
Sent from my iPhone
>
You obviously have too many benches. I will be around to pick up the one you are not using…
I just looked at your Holtzapffel bench in your second bench book and am curious as to which leg will get the new vise, the back of the bench or the end of the bench with the end vise? Have fun with your new toy. That Benchcrafted stuff is beautiful.
The leg currently with the twin screw. So I can swap the two vises.
Thanks. When you wrote “I’ll be able to switch between leg vise and twin-screw with ease.” I wasn’t sure if you meant switching the work piece with ease or the vises.
Is there a Nattering nabob test? (Or did I just qualify by having asked?)
Cool. Would you like a 48 yo intern at LOP?
LAP that is.
One of these days Jameel is going to give you vise hardware that’s threaded backwards just to mess with you.
boyioyioyioyng
I’m about to start my Roubo ish bench (I’ve got a couple things I want to add/ change) and I’ve been trying to decide on vise hardware. I’m interested to know what you think of this one vs. the glide vise with the handwheel.
I imagine the machining tolerances involved the manufacture of the balanced handwheel are responsible for the significant price difference. But I would like to make my decision based on more than just dollars. I don’t think I would consider this version at all, except that they have the wonderful spring loaded catch on the handle. So cool!
Thanks!
I prefer the Classic for its simplicity, its lower price and its old-school look.
But they all hold wood quite well.